Vicar uneasy about religious admissions to schools
And just to prove it isn’t only members of the NSS who are worried about the way religious admissions criteria are applied to schools, the following letter was featured in the Church Times last week. It was from Canon Richard Franklin of Weymouth:
_______________________________________________________________________________
“Am I alone in finding that current discussions about admissions procedures to church secondary schools omit consideration of one of the most embarrassing and morally questionable aspects of the whole business – the part that the clergy and churches have to play in recommending children for admission? I have participated in the annual process for years, but the changes made in 2007 have brought the matter to the fore. The criterion for admission on religious grounds is now much more precise: attendance at church twice a month for a year before application for admission. I understand that the church authorities adopted this policy when the Government insisted that our criteria should be more exact.
It is understandable that the Government wants fairness, clarity, and transparency; but three things have been exacerbated. First, hypocrisy on the part of parents who, seeing that church schools are good, inevitably want to send their children to them: they start coming to church not out of any religious conviction, but simply to get their school of choice.
Second, complicity on the part of the clergy, who are forced to play along, not least because we care about the children, too, and want the best for them. In areas where there is very high demand for places, this can lead to monstrous practices like the taking of registers of attendance over periods of years in advance of admission.
Third, a gross distortion of the Church’s mission in certain areas: churches become filled with families who are there for the sole purpose of getting their children into a desired school, and the real evangelistic task becomes obscured. This results in an overly optimistic picture of where we are.
I am deeply sympathetic to all involved in the operation of this dreadful system. I suppose that in the present atmosphere, where “choice” is god, we have to live with it. But I would plead for a radical re-think of the Church’s position, and hope that in time our church schools will become providers of education with a Christian basis to all the children in their neighbourhood.”
_______________________________________________________________________________________________
And just to show that it is possible to contemplate taking religion out schools, look at this story about just such a proposal from the Ugandan Government
See also:
Prominent rabbi opposes “faith schools”
But the education Minister does not
London’s first state-sponsored Hindu school opens in September
02 May 2008
Make a Donation
Guardian, 21 August 2008
Yorkshire Post, 21 August 2008
Telegraph, 21 August 2008
The fact that this case was won while another case – that of 16- year old Lydia Playfoot and her claim in 2007 to want to wear a “chastity ring” in school – was thrown out of court seems in itself to be discriminatory.
Government transitional safeguards to protect the jobs and promotion prospects of head teachers and teachers already in post in Voluntary Controlled faith schools breach natural justice and are discriminatory, says the National Secular Society.